Moyes: The Postmortem

So after all the hype and fanfare surrounding David Moyes arrival at Manchester United it’s now over, ending in whispers and rumours until this morning when it was announced in a short statement.

So what can be made of the Scotsmans short tenure? Well it was a shambles from start to finish. He wasn’t even in the top 3 of successors United fans wanted when Sir Alex Ferguson announced his retirement so was always going to face an uphill task but he didn’t exactly make things easy for himself. Then in terms of his decision to go against Sir Alex’s advice to keep his back room staff and appoint his own he was also making a rod for his own back, after all the back room staff have played a big part in the success Manchester United had enjoyed in the last 20 years so to clear them all out showed naivety.

Moyes’s first transfer window was a disaster, bringing in Fellaini and not starting to trim the squad down to help mould it in his own vision. He showed no planning in his transfer activity. Manchester United have been crying out for investment for a few years in the midfield, they have been missing the midfield general who is willing to put his foot into the opposition and grab a hold of the game. Likewise the defence needed to be upgraded with 3 of the first choice back 4 out of contract in the summer, last summer would have been the perfect opportunity to bring in Garay or Thiago Silva but no movement came on this. They should have trimmed squad and the likes of Nani, Anderson, Cleverley & Fabio should have gone then. Now as we come to the end of the season no one knows if Ferdinand or Evra will be at the club next year and we know for a fact that Vidic (who would have been the only one of the 3 I would have retained as a member of the playing staff) is off to Inter.

Moyes’s tactics as well were sometimes baffling and you sometimes got the feeling he didn’t know who the best team to put out or where to play them. In what turned out to be his last game in charge against Everton it showed all sorts of issues that have been present all year. Yes United had a lot of possession but with no penetration what so ever, it’s no wonder Rooney was dropping further and further for a touch of the ball because there was nothing coming to him. His substitutions were predictable and forced after he picked the wrong team to play against an Everton team who must have eyes on United’s Champions League place. Other games his idea of get it wide and lump it in to the box early showed a real lack of ideas, with the likes of Mata, Rooney, van Persie, Kagawa & Januzaj on the pitch in any combination there is more than enough talent to carve teams open but they just didn’t ever play to those strengths.

Now we look back and say Moyes always was going on about this being a transitional season but maybe with the right appointment maybe he will proved to be right,but just without him at the helm. You now have to look at the potential people to come in and see what quality of players they can bring into the club.
We have no sympathy for him however as he always looked out of his depth in the Old Trafford hot seat and never seemed to resolve some of the problems that were left by Sir Alex and his ageing squad, as for his future there’s a noises that he may reappear at Spurs or Newcastle and we wish him all the best.

Ry

Advertisements

How to change football for the better.

We all often sit around and offer opinions on how to make football better and here is one we would like to see happen. Lets stop transfers for players under 21. Now we can understand any of you scoffing at the prospect but consider this, how many players under 21 can you say are worth the transfer fees you see banded about for them?

Take for example Luke Shaw of Southampton, now if you were to believe the rumors he is valued at around £30m. £30m for a player who is only just past 50 games for his club and one full England cap is far too much, we can understand Southampton placing that value on his head to try and ward off potential suitors but it shouldn’t be an issue. Southampton are no longer in the position they were with Walcott, Bale or Oxlaide-Chamberlian where they have to sell as they aren’t in the Premiership or in financial difficulty they should simply say he is not for sale full stop.

Daniel Sturridge is another example of youngsters moving about when they are too young, although he himself must take some blame for this one. Sturridge started his career at Manchester City but had his head turned by the money that was on offer from the up and coming billionaire plaything that was Chelsea and allowed his contract to expire. Once at Chelsea his career floundered, he was rarely used as an out and out striker, instead coming on as a wide player where his speed was a great attribute. We are glad he is now showing his true skill and attacking quality now at Liverpool where he has to be in line for featuring in Teams of the Year.

There is also the argument that a player should show a degree of loyalty, after all a young player has been a product of teams youth development system and should show thanks by helping the team to the best of his ability. After all if the player is truly good enough he will still be able to command a big enough fee when he turns 21, thereby giving something back to the club on two levels. We look at some of the situations and tribunals you see (no doubt there will be one this year with Thomas Ince) and clubs rarely get much above £3m and you feel sorry for them as they are losing someone who is probably a star turn for their team. Sometimes as well the players don’t get the benefit either, like we mentioned Sturridge is and example of this, as is Nick Powell, Willfried Zaha and Glenn Johnson (who was Roman Abramovich’s first signing when he came to Chelsea) his progress was majorly held back by that move at 18 and didn’t flourish until he went to Portsmouth and then to Liverpool. We just hope the likes of Shaw & Will Hughes see sense and give something back to the clubs who have shown faith in them.

 

Ryan

Premier League 2013/14 awards, as voted for by the SirZBlog team

It’s been a tremendous Premier League season so far and it’s nearly time for the seasonal awards to be handed out. Check out who the SirZBlog team felt were deserving of them and feel free to add your own suggestions in the comments below.

20140405-124221.jpg

Adamdellboy

Player of the Year – Luis Suarez
Young Player of the Year – Eden Hazard
Manager of the Year – Brendan Rodgers

Team of the Year –

Mignolet
Coleman – Koscielny – Kompany – Shaw
Hazard — Gerrard — Toure — Silva
Suarez — Sturridge

Ross Jones

POTY – Luis Suarez
YPOTY – Luke Shaw
MOTY – Mark Hughes (for getting Stoke passing)

TOTY –

De Gea
Coleman – Kompany – Caulker – Shaw
Barry — Yaya Toure –Hazard –Lallana
Suarez — Rodriguez

Billy Judd

POTY – Luis Suarez
YPOTY – Aaron Ramsey
MOTY – Brendan Rodgers

TOTY –

Szczesny
Coleman – Koscienly – Lovren – Azpilicueta
Ramsey — Toure — Fernandinho
Hazard — Suarez
Sturridge

Ryan De Freitas

POTY – Luis Suarez
YPOY – Raheem Sterling
MOTY – Brendan Rodgers (miracle worker, imo)

TOTY –

Szczesny
Zabaleta – Koscielny – Kompany – Shaw
Yaya Toure — Henderson
Sturridge — Silva — Hazard
Suarez

Andrew Peck

POTY – Luis Suarez
YPOTY – Raheem Sterling
MOTY – Brendan Rodgers

TOTY –

Hart
Shaw – Kompany – Skrtel – Caulker
Hazard — Henderson — Toure — Barkley
Suarez – Sturridge

Ryan Howe

POTY – Luis Suarez
YPOTY – Luke Shaw
MOTY – Brendan Rodgers (although Martinez comes close)

TOTY –

De Gea
Shaw – Dawson – Kompany
Hazard — Yaya Toure — Henderson — Barkley
Rooney – Aguero – Suarez